Introduction
STAR Trusts in the Cayman Islands offer a fresh and creative way to set up trusts, stepping away from the old-fashioned methods. This handy guide to Cayman Island STAR Trusts explores their unique traits, perks, and practical uses. It uncovers why STAR Trusts are a top pick for folks who want to protect and pass down their assets for years ahead with smart inheritance plans.
Defining Cayman Islands Star Trusts
STAR Trusts in the Cayman Islands were established through the Special Trusts (Alternative Regime) Law enacted in 1997, known as the STAR Law. This legislation is now integrated into Part VIII of the revised Trusts Law of the Cayman Islands. Exclusive to the Cayman Islands, STAR Trusts present a legally recognized trust option that can be set up for individuals, specific aims (encompassing both charitable and non-charitable purposes), or a combination of these. It’s crucial to note that the STAR Law only applies if the trust documentation specifies its intended use. This type of trust was developed to resolve certain challenges associated with using more standard offshore trusts in the Cayman Islands.
Key Differences Between STAR Trusts and Standard Trusts
| Feature | STAR Trusts | Standard Trusts |
| Purpose | STAR Trusts can be set up for any lawful individuals or objectives, including charitable, non-charitable, or a mix of both. The trust terms allow for significant flexibility in what the trust aims to achieve. | Standard trusts are generally created for specific beneficiaries, often focusing on charitable or family-related purposes. |
| Perpetuity Period | There is no set time limit for how long a STAR Trust can last. It can potentially continue indefinitely, making it suitable for long-term planning for estates and preserving wealth across many generations. | Standard trusts are usually subject to legal limits on how long they can exist (such as the Rule Against Perpetuities), often around 100 years or less, depending on common law rules. |
| Enforcement | STAR Trusts include an “Enforcer,” a specific role responsible for ensuring the trust achieves its intended purposes. The Enforcer has the sole right and responsibility to enforce the trust’s terms. This separates the role of benefiting from the trust from the role of ensuring the trust is properly carried out. | Standard trusts do not have a formal Enforcer role. Trustees are responsible for both managing the trust and ensuring its purposes are fulfilled. This combines management and enforcement in the trustee’s role. |
| Trustee Requirements | STAR Trusts require a licensed Trust Corporation to act as a trustee. This ensures professional handling and oversight of the trust. | Standard trusts can often be managed by individual people or corporate trustees. Depending on the jurisdiction, there may not be specific licensing requirements for these trustees. |
| Legal Framework | STAR Trusts are primarily governed by the STAR Law, which is specifically designed for their unique structure and objectives. | Standard trusts are governed by the general trust laws applicable in the relevant jurisdiction. There are no specific laws created just for standard trusts. |
Request a Confidential Consultation Today
Speak with one of our experienced offshore legal experts
Key Requirements for a STAR Trust
Explicit Provisions
A STAR Trust must be created using a written document, and this document must clearly state that the STAR Regime is to apply. This requirement makes sure that the person setting up the trust knowingly chooses to use the STAR system. Other than the specific rules of the STAR Regime, the way the trust operates is consistent with traditional trust law.
Role and Authority of the Enforcer
A distinctive aspect of STAR Trusts is the mandatory appointment of one or more enforcers. These enforcers are the only parties legally authorized to ensure the trust is carried out as intended. The person creating the trust can name enforcers when setting up the trust, or the trust document or a court order can specify them. Enforcers can be individuals or organizations and may include beneficiaries, the settlor, or trust protectors.
An enforcer’s role can be either a right they possess or a duty they must perform. If no beneficiary can enforce the trust, it is essential to have at least one enforcer with the obligation and capacity to do so. If needed, a court can step in to appoint an enforcer.
Enforcers are held to similar fiduciary standards as trustees, meaning they are expected to act responsibly and in the best interests of properly executing the trust’s purpose. They have the authority to guide how the STAR Trust is managed, access details about the trust, and seek legal remedies like a beneficiary in a typical trust. When necessary, they can ask the Cayman court for guidance on managing the STAR Trust and have the right to see and obtain copies of trust-related documents. Furthermore, if there’s a breach of trust, enforcers can pursue legal actions against the trustee or others to recover losses or assets, similar to the rights beneficiaries have in traditional trusts. Also, like trustees, enforcers are entitled to be reimbursed from the trust’s funds for costs incurred while carrying out their duties, protecting them from personal financial risk while managing trust responsibilities.
STAR Trusts can be structured to limit or eliminate beneficiaries’ rights to enforce the trust or to get information about the trust’s assets and management. Instead, these informational rights are given to an independent enforcer. This setup is particularly valuable for making sure the trust is managed according to what the settlor intended, without direct intervention from beneficiaries. This can be essential when the goal is to maintain the original purpose of the trust and protect its assets from potential disputes among beneficiaries.
Trustee Qualifications
A STAR Trust must include at least one trustee that meets the definition of a ‘Trust Corporation’ as defined in Section 2 of the Cayman Trusts Act:
“…means a corporate entity licensed to conduct trust business, with or without limitations, under the Banks and Trust Companies Act (2021 Revision) or officially registered under that Act as a controlled subsidiary or a private trust company.”
However, it’s permissible to have additional trustees who do not meet this definition, provided that at least one trustee does qualify.
Clarity and Purpose Modification (Cy-près)
The term “cy-près,” originating from Norman French, generally means, particularly regarding changes to charitable trust purposes, that the trust’s objectives should be followed “as closely as possible” to the settlor’s initial aim. In the context of Cayman Islands STAR Trusts, the cy-près principle allows for the modification of a trust if fulfilling its original purpose becomes impossible, impractical, illegal, or against public policy due to changed circumstances. This ensures that the overarching intent of the trust can still be achieved.
The non-charitable objectives of a STAR Trust must comply with public policy and the laws of the Cayman Islands. The trust should not be considered invalid because its objectives or method of execution are unclear. The trustee or another designated individual has the authority to resolve any ambiguities. If necessary, the Cayman courts can also step in to modify the trust through a court order.
The case of CIBC Bank and Trust Company (Cayman) Limited v T & S (CIBC v T & S) is an example of how the cy-près principle is applied to STAR Trusts. In this instance, the trustee asked the Cayman court to modify the trusts using cy-près because the trusts’ original purpose had become outdated. This was because the main beneficiary had moved to a different tax jurisdiction. This change meant that the trust’s original goals could no longer be met under its current terms.
The court agreed that, due to these changed circumstances, the original intent of the trust could not be achieved without changes. Consequently, the court used its power to modify the trust under the cy-près principle. In this situation, this meant adjusting the trust in a way that would align as closely as possible with what the settlor originally intended, while taking into account the new circumstances. This ruling offered important clarification on how to apply the cy-près principle to STAR Trusts, confirming that it should be interpreted similarly to its application in charitable trust situations.
Cayman Islands Property
A STAR Trust is not permitted to directly or indirectly own land located in the Cayman Islands. However, it is allowed to hold interests in companies that own Cayman land as part of their business operations.
Speak with One of Our Offshore Legal Experts
All Inquiries & Consultations Remain 100% Confidential
What’s the Purpose of a STAR Trust?
Business Purposes
- Ownerless Special Purpose Vehicles: In the business world, STAR Trusts are frequently used to make Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) “ownerless.” This is advantageous for keeping assets separate from company balance sheets or setting up structures that are protected if bankruptcy occurs. Appointing private enforcers for these trusts lowers the risks of enforcement issues and increases confidentiality. This is unlike traditional charitable trusts, where the Attorney General is responsible for enforcement. Therefore, in complex finance and other deals, STAR Trusts act as SPVs, enabling “off-balance sheet” or bankruptcy-protected transactions because they are not connected to the original parties involved in the transaction.
- Operating Businesses: They are also employed to hold ownership of operating companies in a manner that limits how much the trustee is involved in the day-to-day running of the business. This is also useful for investments in family businesses where the financial performance might be uncertain.
- Family Business Continuity: STAR Trusts can be used to guarantee that family businesses continue to operate smoothly after the owner passes away. The trust holds shares in the business, which allows the management to continue running the company.
Family and Estate Planning Purposes
- Orphaning Private Trust Companies: STAR Trusts are used to “orphan” private trust companies that act as trustees for family trusts. This setup gives families more control and oversight compared to using a trust company that is not related to the family.
- Long-term Family Trusts: Because STAR Trusts are not limited by the usual 150-year duration limit, they are well-suited for creating long-lasting private or family trusts designed to last for generations.
- Owning Private Trust Companies: It’s common to set up a STAR Trust to own the shares of a Private Trust Company. This PTC then serves as the trustee for one or more other trusts, possibly in different countries. This structure helps avoid problems with who owns the PTC when ownership needs to be transferred due to death or other reasons.
Charitable and Community Projects
STAR Trusts can also be used to support projects that benefit the public or specific communities, such as maintaining local facilities or preserving historical sites. Examples include funding the operations of an opera house or supporting political causes.
These diverse uses illustrate how adaptable STAR Trusts are for meeting a wide array of needs, from structuring businesses and managing family wealth to supporting charitable activities and controlling how beneficiaries receive their entitlements.
Advantages of Using a Cayman Islands Trust
Choosing the Cayman Islands for setting up trusts offers several key benefits, making it a desirable location:
- Legislation Protection: The Cayman Islands’ Trusts Act includes legislation that acts as a protective barrier for trusts established there. This protection shields Cayman trusts from claims originating outside the jurisdiction against the trust’s assets. This includes challenges from individuals claiming inheritance rights or claims arising from personal connections to a beneficiary. It also provides a defense against rulings from foreign courts that do not respect the laws of the Cayman Islands concerning trusts.
- Flexible Company Regulations: The Cayman Islands have company laws that are flexible and easily adjusted, which aligns well with the requirements of most major global stock exchanges. This Flexibility is essential for setting up companies that need to operate on an international scale.
- Reliable Legal System: The Cayman Islands are known for having a highly developed and dependable legal system. This is a crucial factor to ensure that a STAR Trust can be properly managed and its terms enforced.
- International Recognition: Cayman is globally recognized as a leading international financial center, enhancing its attractiveness as a location for trusts and other types of financial arrangements.
- Tax Neutrality: The Cayman Islands offer a tax-neutral environment, meaning that trusts established there are not subject to direct taxation. This is advantageous for maximizing the financial performance of the assets held within the trust.
- Compliance with Global Standards: Cayman is committed to international compliance standards. This ensures that its financial practices meet worldwide regulatory expectations and helps maintain its reputation as a respected financial location.
- Efficient and Cost-Effective Setup: Setting up both companies and trusts in the Cayman Islands is efficient in terms of cost and process. This makes it simpler for individuals and businesses to establish and administer their trusts.
Taken together, these elements make the Cayman Islands a favored jurisdiction for establishing trusts, especially for those seeking strong legal safeguards, financial advantages, and international acceptance.
International Recognition of STAR Trusts
Despite some early questions regarding whether STAR Trusts would be recognized outside the Cayman Islands, there have been no known legal cases that have effectively contested their legitimacy or refused to acknowledge them as valid trust arrangements in other countries. A STAR Trust typically aligns with the definition of a ‘trust’ as outlined in The Hague Convention on the Law Applicable to Trusts. Given that Cayman law, which is the governing law selected by the trust creator, determines the legitimacy of a STAR Trust, it follows that in nations that have adopted the Convention, a STAR Trust is typically expected to be acknowledged as a valid trust. This international recognition highlights the efficacy and strength of STAR Trusts as a legal and financial tool.
Conclusion
STAR Trusts stand out as a highly developed instrument for managing wealth strategically and planning for the future of assets, providing exceptional adaptability and security. Their capacity to serve diverse objectives, together with the strong legal safeguards provided by the Cayman Islands, makes them a highly attractive option for individuals and families aiming to protect and grow their wealth for generations to come.
For anyone thinking about setting up a STAR Trust or wanting to learn more about how they could be used, it is essential to speak with knowledgeable estate planning experts. Samoa Offshore Legal is well-prepared to offer the specialized advice and assistance necessary to understand the intricacies of STAR Trusts and optimize their advantages for your estate planning objectives. Contact us today to learn more!
